I am eating leftover Papa Murphy's pizza right now as I type. I reheat it in a hot pan so the crust gets crispy and I like it better than last night's "fresh outta the oven" zah. LOL
Reheated pizza? Nope! Gotta be Stine cold out the fridge with either an ice cold coke (if I've gotta work) or an ice cold beer (if I'm off)!
Suggest you go to the Lounge, and check out "strange family food traditions"-- it's getting almost weird enough to appeal to you gents...