Caribbean Garden Seed is a pretty infamous seed company, known for scamming people according to their Better Business Bureau profile. When people bought seeds and tulips from them on their website, they either didn't arrive or arrived in awful condition. The behavior by the company is so bad that one buyer wants you to
call the police.
According to Better Business Bureau and the Pennsylvania government archives, this company has been in business for seven years with an LLC registration date of September 21, 2015. Etsy archives say that it was in business for longer. The Etsy archives circa 2013-2014 have loads of 5-star reviews.
(Pictured on September 28, 2014)
An important question to ask is "where did it all go wrong?"
I have two theories.
Theory 1 is that the company has always been scammy, and they've been manipulating reviews. This is supported by several allegations in their reviews on BBB and Google that most, if not all positive reviews are by the company itself or people affiliated with it. It's also supported by the fact that the grammar on the shop was unchanged between its Etsy and website incarnation.
According to a theory, many scammers purposefully type with unproper grammar to catch people who aren't paying attention. I'm not telling you to judge a company based on proper grammar firsthand, you really shouldn't, but this grammar is just one of the attributes of some scams.
Theory 2 is that the company was bought out. This is supported by the trademark filing date being after the business was on Etsy, and the possibility of the "review manipulation" theory not being true. It's also supported by the fact that its Etsy account was banned without warning, after people started reacting negatively to it.