soil Fertilizing soil vs soilless

CanadaChili

CanadaChili

Oddly enough, I first started growing peppers in hydroponics and soilless (ie. peat-based) mixes and I'm just beginning to grow my chilies directly in the soil.
When fertilizing in the soil, is it only necessary to provide additional NPK as opposed to supplying all nutrients (molybdenum, zinc or copper for eg) in soilless? If I were to be fertilizing a plant with 1000ppm of fertilizer, would the same plant in soil require only a fraction of that?

Thanks in advance and happy gardening [emoji892]️

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 
Good question. One would think soil already has sufficient micro nutrients but I think the only way to tell would be to have your soil tested
 
Thanks. I have a bunch of hydro fertilizers kicking around and like to use those ones up first. Generally speaking, would it make sense to scale back nutrient strength when feeding plants in soil? To what degree I'll have to test that myself.

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 
CanadaChili said:
Oh right, I think I've seen those before. 4-3-3?

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
 
Just any organic fert.  You'll be hard pressed to see the difference between one organic dry fertilizer and another, unless there's something more than just NPK in it.
 
I do a liquid feed every week or two in my raised beds.  I use the recommended dosage for intermediate stage plants.  I mean, where I live, it rains so much, that there's no point in dumping gallons of nutrients in, that I'm going to have to continually replenish.  I prefer liquid nutrients, because critters don't dig everything up, like they do when I used dry ferts.   2 days ago, a raccoon totally dug up a new plant out...  Wouldn't have happened with the liquid nutes.
 
CanadaChili said:
Thanks. I have a bunch of hydro fertilizers kicking around and like to use those ones up first. Generally speaking, would it make sense to scale back nutrient strength when feeding plants in soil? To what degree I'll have to test that myself.

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
 
50% would be a pretty good baseline for using hydronutes in soil.
 
Planting in soil, you'll get a ton of added benefit by mulching around your plants.  Put dry fertilizer under the mulch layer. (no matter what kind you end up using)  
 
solid7 said:
 
Just any organic fert.  You'll be hard pressed to see the difference between one organic dry fertilizer and another, unless there's something more than just NPK in it.
 
I do a liquid feed every week or two in my raised beds.  I use the recommended dosage for intermediate stage plants.  I mean, where I live, it rains so much, that there's no point in dumping gallons of nutrients in, that I'm going to have to continually replenish.  I prefer liquid nutrients, because critters don't dig everything up, like they do when I used dry ferts.   2 days ago, a raccoon totally dug up a new plant out...  Wouldn't have happened with the liquid nutes.
Click to expand...
Just out of curiosity what do you use for your liquid feed?

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 
A good cheap dry organic is alfalfa meal. Slow to release/work though. Farm and Feed stores sell 50lb bags cheap. Its very good for adding to your compost pile also.
 
Chilidude said:
 
50% would be a pretty good baseline for using hydronutes in soil.
Click to expand...
Alright thanks! I never use the manufacturer's dosing recommendations as they are almost always too strong. I'll just start light and scale up nutrient strength as needed

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 
CanadaChili said:
Just out of curiosity what do you use for your liquid feed?

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
 
Alaska Fish 5-1-1 is my go-to.  It's cheap, readily available, lasts a long time, and WORKS.  It's especially great in soil, because N is the nutrient you'll need to replenish the most.   P and K are already abundant in most soils, and don't really need much replenishing.
 
solid7 said:
 
Alaska Fish 5-1-1 is my go-to.  It's cheap, readily available, lasts a long time, and WORKS.  It's especially great in soil, because N is the nutrient you'll need to replenish the most.   P and K are already abundant in most soils, and don't really need much replenishing.
Click to expand...
I've heard lots of good things with the fish ferts, besides the smell. Are you switching that out with something containing less nitrogen when your plants start blooming?

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 
Fish emulsion is the main thing i use in ground too. I change nothing during blooming/budding. Liquid kelp is also a good addition to the fish emulsion. Kelp meal if you can get it cheap enough.
 
CanadaChili said:
I've heard lots of good things with the fish ferts, besides the smell. Are you switching that out with something containing less nitrogen when your plants start blooming?

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
 
No, because the idea of switching to "bloom" mode is pure myth.  It's a marketing gimmick.

Fish fert only smells bad before you dilute it.  Once it's watered in, it's not even noticeable.
 
solid7 said:
 
No, because the idea of switching to "bloom" mode is pure myth.  It's a marketing gimmick.
Fish fert only smells bad before you dilute it.  Once it's watered in, it's not even noticeable.
Click to expand...
Too much nitrogen doesn't cause blossom drop? So a x(3-1-2) would be suitable throughout the entire growing season?

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 
CanadaChili said:
Too much nitrogen doesn't cause blossom drop? So a x(3-1-2) would be suitable throughout the entire growing season?

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
 
Sure, too much nitrogen causes blossom drop - in the same way that driving your car too fast into a wall will cause the car to wrinkle up.  That is, you'd have to overdo it to the point of toxicity.  This is easy to do with either salt-based ferts, or ammonium based (manure).  But if you use the recommended amount of 3-1-2 - or even a little more - you're going to be just fine.  Good luck overdosing, if you use any other organic source.
.
I have heard this nitrogen rumor for years, but nobody ever bothered to tell my garden, because she just keeps on cranking them out...
.
I mentioned the Alaska Fish earlier for soil, but in containers, or raised beds, I also rotate with a 3-1-2.  I rotate organic and inorganic nutrient sources, but it has nothing to do with nutrient cycling, for me.
 
solid7 said:
 
Sure, too much nitrogen causes blossom drop - in the same way that driving your car too fast into a wall will cause the car to wrinkle up.  That is, you'd have to overdo it to the point of toxicity.  This is easy to do with either salt-based ferts, or ammonium based (manure).  But if you use the recommended amount of 3-1-2 - or even a little more - you're going to be just fine.  Good luck overdosing, if you use any other organic source.
.
I have heard this nitrogen rumor for years, but nobody ever bothered to tell my garden, because she just keeps on cranking them out...
.
I mentioned the Alaska Fish earlier for soil, but in containers, or raised beds, I also rotate with a 3-1-2.  I rotate organic and inorganic nutrient sources, but it has nothing to do with nutrient cycling, for me.
Click to expand...
Interesting...I appreciate the advice. Funny that you say that because I have grown habs in a nutrient flow hydro setup and they shared the same nutrients as lettuce and Swiss chard. Basically the overall ratio was more or less balanced with a little more nitrogen to green everything up. Thing grew into a tree and it didn't seem to affect the production.
Cheers

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top