Why don't you take the right column (# Used) and make it descending (18, 17, 16...) so it is easy to see the most used ingredients, and then, the left column (Ingredients) would be in the order of most used, instead of alphabetical. This also follows the logic of reading ingredients on the side of a product, which are listed in order of amount. Also recipes usually follow this logic as well. Alphabetical is not really needed, there is no point. If allspice is almost never used it should not be first. When designing my own recipe I'd like to see what is used most to least easily.
If these were tables on a computer and you could click to sort each column, that would be ideal!