Version 1 is going great guns, almost 100% sprouting (of the seeds I expected to sprout).
Version 2... well still in the planning stages. Finding the right sized tubing is a pain, can buy it either the same size as ver1 (or smaller) as drip hose, or much bigger as plumbing pipe. The right size? Well I've seen it as oversized drinking straws, they are just a little harder to come by.
Decided to open up one of the tubes to see how the growth of roots were, here are the pics.
Tube with towel and seedling.
Towel and seedling removed from tube.
Naked seedling with root exposed.
They are now outside in the Autumn air in a little "
greenhouse", will see what happens next.