Hey Greeny,
About your list, here's my take...
Marie Sharp's is great for taste, but I have had to hit the top of their sauces heat scale (No Wimps Allowed or the BEWARE) before getting enough heat to match the taste profile. The Fiery Hot is kind of a low simmer sorta heat.
The Crazy Jerry sauces are WAY underrated, IMHO. You may want to get their gift box so you can try the Orange Rush, also. Another fab sauce.
Scorned Woman? Decent sauce, but never struck me as anything extraordinary. Always seemed just a little hotter than Cholula to me. You likely won't be disappointed, but you can do better.
Thumbs up on the Danny Cash sauce. The Radical Heat is one of my faves of his.
Pain is Good is not one I've tried...probably because I feel like I see it everywhere. I think I can get it at my local Giant Eagle grocery store. It's an "Original Juan" sauce, meaning they're all about marketing.
The Matouk's is totally a keeper. It's a gi-normous bottle of mouth-searing goodness. Pretty inexpensive too.
You seem to be a habanero sorta guy. Invest in a bottle of "Ace" or "Ignite" from CaJohn, Blair's "Sudden Death," or Scotty B's "Just Damn Good" sauces. They rock.
- Joe