Strength of visible light is only one consideration.
1w LED = 1w HID = 1w Fl. The additional spectrum coverage of floro and hid and the heat produced are beneficial to the plant biology. I find that LEDs dont produce enough radiant heat.
The LEDs you will find are made by a couple Chinese companies that while impressive due to the visible output, have no penetration and small variations in the power that can result in the wrong wavelength production. This is why the "professional" level lights have Cree diodes with a coned lense to spread the light. I'm sure they're going to get better (they have) but they're only good for supplimental light. You can grow plenty big tomatoes, basil, peppers into vegitation but it will be slow. I professional light will cost 400 or more. The typical cree puck light 3w costs around $7 last time I checked. Put 50 of those together, power supplies, housing.... the math works out.
The cheap ones seem to have serious hot spots too and hit plants like lasers with too much intensity in areas.
I would DEFINITELY use one in a window to suppliment daylight though. Aside from the fan noise, it is low power and can give enough boost for houseplants and germinating the ones for your garden in the coming season.....but the demographic that tends to use them rarely puts those plants in the window, LOL.
MHz