artwork Logo input needed-Pure Evil products

[salsalady]

Hey gang,
 
We're working on revamping the Pure Evil product line, new website, and updated look. 
 
The existing Pure Evil capsaicin drops have black on red labels like #1, and I've used the same black on red for promotional materials in the past.  For the new items, the labels will have yellow on black like picture #2 below.  These are the colors used on product labels. 
 
PE Logo/Label #1

PE Logo #2

 
 
I'm looking for a Logo color design to use for t-shirts, promo materials, website, and I've put together the following two designs. 
 
What do y'all think?  One of the following 2? or keep the original black-on-red even though there will be 2 design color schemes for the different products? 
 
Logo #3

 
Logo #4

 

[The Hot Pepper]

#vintage

 

[Lucky Dog Hot Sauce]

Have you tried red outlined in yellow against black?

I kinda prefer the black on red but the yellow outlined with red on black is growing on me.

#methow

cave_drawings.jpg

FIFY

 

[salsalady]

I've done several outlined samples and the color scheme suggested.  They look good!  In the long term plan of things, the oulined logos will be the NextGen.  It'll be a bit of a step transition.  Colors, fonts, outlines, names, brands, ...they will all come together eventually. 

 

[D3monic]

#4, didn't read all the changes though.