I heard that Cajun = no tomatoes, Creole = tomatoes. I have no idea though.
-
We welcome content that is not political, divisive, or offensive. If we feel your content leans this way or has the potential to, it may be removed at any time. A hot pepper forum is not the place for such content. Thank you for respecting the community!
-
✅ Expert and friendly hot pepper grow advice.
✅ The latest information on hot pepper varieties.
✅ Reliable seed trading.
✅ Hot sauce recipes and food safety guidance.
✅ Hot sauce business tips for startups.
🌶️ And more!
It's all here, at The Hot Pepper! The Internet's original hot pepper community! Est. 2004.
food-bev AJs Gumbo from scratch...
- Thread starter AlabamaJack
- Start date
you dont' have to yell...
What?
Well, me being originally from deep south Mississippi, growing up in Mobile and Pensacola, then moving to Texas...lets just call it mixed up gulf coast gumbo...I use tomatos in almost every dish...I love them...so I must be a creole cook.... 
Guud Gulf Gumbo
Trademark it AJ!
Trademark it AJ!
I am all trademarked out...325 a whack is kinda expensive boss...
Oh not meaning to yell AJ - but boy that hit a nerve. As stated in several post - cajun cooking does not use tomatoes while creole does. Just a thing, from below N.O. say around Chalmette to around the New Orleans/river region they do use tomatoes in gumbo as they also make a red Jambalaya. But for Cajuns on the bayou - Bayou Lafourche from Thibodeaux down to Larose going westward to Lafayette area - there is no red in gumbos or jambalaya.
People around here have had fights over this, as no loyal cajun would ever want to hear of, see, or eat a red gumbo or jambalaya. They feel the whole reason of making a roux is to have a brown base and to be able to taste the roux without the red stuff. Sort of nullifies the whole idea of making a pretty brown roux to the darkness you desire then muddling it all up with red stuff. In this area, Red gravies, sauces, and dishes are reserved for Fish Courtbouillon or whatever kind of Sauce Piquante you want to cook. But to each his own - your gumbo still looked good.
Go to this site and there is a little write up about it- but as you can see there is a lot of blending also going on in some areas. In fact look at the receipts, some have the tomatoes in the gumbo but the majority do not. http://www.chefrick.com/cajun-recipes
Take Care and keep on cooking.
People around here have had fights over this, as no loyal cajun would ever want to hear of, see, or eat a red gumbo or jambalaya. They feel the whole reason of making a roux is to have a brown base and to be able to taste the roux without the red stuff. Sort of nullifies the whole idea of making a pretty brown roux to the darkness you desire then muddling it all up with red stuff. In this area, Red gravies, sauces, and dishes are reserved for Fish Courtbouillon or whatever kind of Sauce Piquante you want to cook. But to each his own - your gumbo still looked good.
Go to this site and there is a little write up about it- but as you can see there is a lot of blending also going on in some areas. In fact look at the receipts, some have the tomatoes in the gumbo but the majority do not. http://www.chefrick.com/cajun-recipes
Take Care and keep on cooking.
Damn sounds like the beans vs. no beans thang for chili! WAR!
I like my Jambalaya with a bit of tomatoes sometime....
...gumbo without.
...gumbo without.