False alarm... I think they were just too cold and wet. I put them in a warmer, sunnier spot and now they're fully perked up again.
I've been holding off on transplanting them until the temps stay above 50 consistently and then they're going straight into my raised bed. It's insane how cold May has been here. Really disappointing.
I am in NJ too and my plants have been outside as well. 44f night should not do that to your plants. How long have you had them outside?
How are your plants doing this year? I would love to see how people from NJ are gettin along this season