I can say that my BGE is everything I wished for and more. One of the best purchases I have ever made. I am still learning temperature control, like how much fuel for different things, but it is a wonderfully tasty adventure. Everything I have cooked on it has been terrific. I am a believer and would recommend it to anyone! It was fun re-reading this thread and all the stuff I said last year. Turns out I did everything I said I was going to, I did buy a Weber gas grill before I bought the Egg. Now it is pretty much a $600 rack to set my Egg stuff on while I grill. I will still use it to make hot dogs or whatever, but so far I have not used it since I bought the Egg.