PepperDaddy said:
[SIZE=medium]Thanks for the input. I welcome constructive criticism and am considering changing my name. My “play on words” is apparently confusing to most. [/SIZE]
[SIZE=medium]What you are saying is correct when used as a verb. But when used as a noun, a mill is also a factory. I don’t know which online dictionaries are best, but thefreedictionary.com (
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Mill), under item 5, lists a mill as: [/SIZE]
- [SIZE=medium]A building or group of buildings equipped with machinery for processing raw materials into finished or industrial products: a textile mill; a steel mill.[/SIZE]
- [SIZE=medium]A building or collection of buildings that has machinery for manufacture; a factory.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=medium]A steel mill does not just cut or grind. It takes raw ore or pig iron, liquefies it, separates impurities, shapes it, rolls it, etc. A textile mill takes fabrics and weaves, sews and builds clothing. thefreedictionary.com also lists your definition “A building equipped with machinery for grinding grain into flour or meal.” [/SIZE]
Well, I used the Websters - probably slightly better than the free online dictionary, but that's splitting hairs.
But make no mistake: a Mill is not called that because it is "a building or collection of buildings that have machinery for manufacture; a factory" - a factory is a looser definition, and if you called your company "pepper factory" it would be sensible.
But while true that a mill is a factory, not all factories are mills, which is where you're off-base. A mill is a very specific type of factory - one that mills things. Milling is a grinding, or cutting down (metals/grains/textiles) and while all of those examples are on point, it is not a natural association to go from specific (milling) to general (the place where milling takes place = factory, by loose definition). Example: a steel mill performs milling, among the other indications. But it is called a mill for a very specific reason. It has machinery used in the milling process.
Again, I'm not the end all be all here, but I do enjoy language debates, and this is a good one. Here's what Websters has:
:
1 a building provided with machinery for grinding grain into flour
2
a : a machine or apparatus (as a quern) for grinding grain
b : a machine for crushing or comminuting
[/QUOTE]Note: the 1st or 2nd definitions are the most commonly understood meaning of the word. If the free online dictionary has it 5th (Websters had your definition 4th btw) then it's unlikely to be commonly understood - the synonym "factory" would be more fitting which is why they provide it.
Ironically, if you left your company name alone, and produced ground peppers as your 1st line of product, and became known for your ground pepper powders, then LATER came out with a line of hot sauces, no one would even blink. They'd just say, "hey, you try that new line of hot sauces from the pepper mill? Yeah - they're great!" But if you start with hot sauce, people will be confused.
If you meant pepper factory (general term), then call it pepper factory. The presence of the word "mill" brings up a very narrow and specific type of factory, and one that would not ordinarily be associated with hot sauce (or any liquid for that matter).
I'll see what name suggestions I can think of, but in my opinion, "mill" is going to be confusing to people. That said, it's your company and you can name it whatever you want.