I also prefer the smoothness of a fermented pepper mash hot sauce as it has become my favorite method this year. I have not tried your hooch method but will start some as soon as I get some distilled, I'm just adding back some already fermented mash to each new batch. This is one of the better threads on fermentation period and hope more people discover this old way of food preservation. Good read.
PRP:
Like yourself,I too have become very fond of the smoothness you get from the fermenting method.
I have made four small batches of hot sauce(approx. 2 bottles each) 2-using fermented habanero and 2- fermented cayenne...and between what I use and what my friends have snagged, I'm probably going to be going without very soon.
Currently,I have six different mash's fermenting of my own,some with air locks and others in small crocks.
And after reading up on all the various "starter" options,I used whey (from plain yogurt)as a starter. The whey worked perfectly, was ready to use after waiting about an hour for it to separate, and I had none of the nurturing necessary with a sour dough starter.
I've got to admit....I believe I'm hooked on the method...no...I know I'm hooked.
The smoothness and depth of the flavor is simply too hard to ignore.
I have also done some other fermenting projects this season:
two 1/2 gal batches of Kim Chi,
one 1/2 gal of traditional sauerkraut,
and some fermented pickled green tomatoes (around 20).
The only thing I still have left are a few of the pickled green tomatoes....and I don't expect them to last much longer than this weekend.
They are absolutely great...and in the past, I have never liked green tomatoes in the slightest.
And to your point...after my first batch of Kim Chi was ready to put in the fridge, I used 3-4 TBS of the liquid as a starter in a batch of pepper mash...then in the sauerkraut...then in the next batch of mash...etc.
It works like a charm.
CM