tctenten said:f**k...I am confused. I need to do more reading on this.
We're talking about dextrines ... and like beta-glucan too, I guess ...
The CaraPils, CaraFOAM etc are body enhancing specialty grains ...
Wheebz not-so-gently let me know that I was misusing them, and that they are more commonly used to add body to lighter colored beers, and maybe sweetness to a lesser extent that the lactose/maltose ...
You don't see people putting lactose in IPA's that I've seen, mostly just stout, so it's probably that it counters the perception of the hops or something (I really don't know jack shit about IPA's) ...
I used lactose to try to add sweetness to counter the spicy of the ghost pepper syrup ... that syrup is legitimately pepper-y ... a teaspoon out of the bottle makes your whole mouth tingle ...
I added maltodextrin to add an unfermentable sugar to the beer, so that it would remain behind after fermentation (yeast can't ferment it) to increase the perception of thickness/body or whatever you want to call it ...
Flaked Rye and Flaked Oats were also in there ...
I threw everything and the kitchen sink at it, because while my Darkness Everybody is very tasty and immensely drinkable - I have a beer-boner for a chewy, thick stout along the lines of Bourbon County or Marshall Zhukov etc ...
I wanted to see the other side of the line, and to be able to dial it back on my 2nd attempt to try to nail it in 2 passes, instead of creeping it up, creeping it up, creeping it up and having to drink 7-8 gallons of beer just trying to get there ...
I did feel like it was a good plan, having tried and not liked spicy pepper beer attempts that I've bought along the way, and I think in that respect doing a lot of that stuff was necessary or the beer would be too hot ...
So, yeah ... that beer's whacky, man ...
But, all of the drama is not really indicative of anything ...
I thought it might be done when it was, and it is, and it was ...
The extra krausening yeast infusions did nothing, the beer was fermented down to like 1.038-1.040 and that's what it really is ...
Those first 5x days of ferm, were the ferm ... all of the ferm thereafter has been because it was just processing the sugars in the starter wort from each additional pitch, and the only reason the gravity lowered at all was because 1600mL of canned starter wort was added (probably 1.030-ish), which is lower than the 3 gallons of 1.040 (+/- .002) from the mixing in of weaker wort ...
So ... lots to learn from this experience. I brew fine, ferm ran fine, and I got what I designed ...
Next time I won't design quite as extreme of an unfermentable wort, and I'll be in there ...
I made that recipe on purpose, knowing it was overdoing it, and willing to take my licks once Wheebz saw it ... you'll notice I tried not to post it, LOL ...
In fact, I'll copy and paste his response from email when I sent him the recipe finally: "maltodextrim and cara pils was the dumbest addition ever" ...
But, you know - being me, I wanted to blaze my own trail for batch #10 ... what can I tell you, I'm prone to op-positional defiance =) ...
As far as researching a lot, it's podcasts ... I haven't read much at all, but I've listened to years worth of podcasts while I work during the day, and late at night ...
I feel like I don't know much at all yet, and wish HTH would post more and that there were more experienced folks than just Wheebz ...
HTH was sporting a collection of neck weights from contests, last time he dropped by =) ...