I've always been a print-catalog fan.
I have a small stack here, and I am ALWAYS thumbing through them. I guess it's the closest thing I have to a Encyclopedia of hot sauces. They get used a LOT, and some have been here a couple years. I find them much easier to browse than a web site.
Examples... Well, I kind of like the layout and feel of MoHotta MoBetta's site. But I hate having to click-click-click just read something. Their print catalog is much better.
Firegirl has a very active review section for their sauces by users. Unfortunately, they're most AOL type reviews. However, sometimes they're funny. But just not useful. Also, her descriptions are all there on one page, but it's kind of ugly, and hard to tell where one sauce starts and ends.
Peppers.com wastes too much space for each sauce, and yet doesn't show a picture, or description, or very many at once. When listing sauces that way, squish them together like a spreadsheet and put as many as possible on one page.
Insane Chicken has what I like for descriptions, number-per-page is high, and big pictures. Probably kills his bandwidtch too, but it is what I like.