• If you have a question about commercial production or the hot sauce business, please post in Startup Help.

Need Reviewers for my Hot Sauce

Well I’m finally at a point where I think my sauce is ready for prime time.  So I guess that means I need reviewers to cut it down to size and send me back to the drawing board.  I just started my company and am trying to finalize 4 sauces.  I need fellow chileheads to provide honest and detailed feedback on each sauce and rank them.  I have a 5th sauce that is a duplicate of another and I must have added too many habs and it was hotter than I wished.  I will include that bottle as a bonus. 
 
I have checked into shipping and it looks like the cheapest option is USPS medium flat rate box.  So I ask that anyone wishing to participate send a 10 spot back in the mail to cover most of the shipping cost.  I’m okay working off a gentleman’s agreement.  We’ll call it a digital handshake.
 
For feedback I have a Word form to complete.  It contains radio buttons for rating the sauce on various properties, such as too hot, too sweet, flavor, consistency, etc.  There is unlimited room for freeform comments.  Of course, anyone is free to send back additional feedback in other mediums as well.  All I ask is that feedback not be posted publically.  I guess I’m just not comfortable with that yet  :P
 
I will also provide a list of ingredients and a flavor profile.  These are all natural, preservative-free sauces.  They are medium heat and targeted to the average chilehead.  I would rank them between a 2-2.5 on a scale of 1 to 5.  No superhots yet, but they will come  ;).  Here is a general description of the sauces and ingredients.  It is not a full ingredient list but enough to get a feel for the sauce:
 
Rio Grande Mud
  • Think chili.  Use with BBQ, steak, beef, turkey, eggs and anything Mexican
  • Savory sauce w/ guajillo, chipotle, de Arbol, habs, garlic, chocolate, coffee
 
Red Thunder (and RT XHOT)
  • Think BBQ.  Use with pork, chicken, pizza, pasta and just about anything
  • Sweet sauce w/ red habs, chipotle, carrot, ginger, red bell pepper, brown sugar, tamarind
 
Mustard Bomb  
  • Use as mustard replacement – brats, burgers, hot dogs, pork, chicken, BBQ, et
  • Savory sauce w/ jalapenos, serranos, orange habs, poblanos, yellow bell, carrot, ginger, scallions
 
Island Sunshine
  • Good with BBQ, chicken, fish, pizza, mac & cheese, Mexican
  • Sweet sauce w/ fresh pineapple, orange habs, orange and lemon juice, ginger, honey
 
So in short, you provide feedback and $10 and get 5 rockin’ bottles of hot sauce.  If you are cool w/ this arrangement, please PM me.  I will take the first 10 or so responses.
 
Here are some picks:
 

Attachments

  • P1040612.JPG
    P1040612.JPG
    217.4 KB · Views: 129
  • P1040617.JPG
    P1040617.JPG
    83.3 KB · Views: 122
  • P1040615.JPG
    P1040615.JPG
    86.1 KB · Views: 106
  • P1040616.JPG
    P1040616.JPG
    87 KB · Views: 118
  • P1040614.JPG
    P1040614.JPG
    86.9 KB · Views: 108
  • P1040618.JPG
    P1040618.JPG
    88.8 KB · Views: 114
I would like to thank everyone who completed the reviews.  I wanted to post this sooner but have been waiting for input that has not arrived. 
 
Overall, reviews were very positive and each sauce was someone’s favorite.  In short, RGM, IS and MB received 30% each as a favorite with 10% for RT.  However, RT was ranked 2nd by almost everyone and given “everyday” sauce status.  I think the wide range of results is due to the variety of sauces that appeal to many different tastes.
 
There have been several good recommendations, some of which I have incorporated or tried:
  • MB: I roasted some of the vegetables, added scotch bonnets and added more spices and herbs to give a little more depth.
  • RGM: I tried replacing the red habs w/ chocolate habs.  Jury is still out.  Some liked this so much I am reluctant to change it except for slightly more heat.
  • IS:  I increased the heat level and replaced the cayenne with red habs.  I also replaced the orange habs w/ scotch bonnets.  I’m still working on this one.
  • RT: Little to do here but may reduce honey slightly and add a touch more chipotle.
 
Thanks again to everyone for your feedback.  It was very helpful and I know my sauces are better now than when I started this exercise.  Next stop is labels, co-packer quotes and then Kickstarter! 
 
Ken
 
Back
Top