Thanks guys, and agreed, c26 - I prefer my steak mooing, too. However, I've never cooked steak like that before, and didn't know what a time difference putting it into the hot cast iron would make. For a steak that size, I was expecting 7 minutes on one side, then a bit longer on the other, but when I opened the oven door (no window) after 7 minutes, it clearly needed no more time in the oven. Live and learn! This was entirely shooting from the hip - I didn't think about broiling it in the cast iron until the last minute. Cooking steak like that is something I'll definitely do again, even if I don't stuff it - yummmmm!