We had a great time at hot pepper night, last night. We had 16 people eating out of the fried hot pepper basket and 10 people, both men and women, participated in last night's new test. Didn't get to burn up any new people, just old hands going at it. A good mix of people though. Just thinking, there were 3 people who make sauce, half of the group are growing their own hot peppers, two people make hot salsa, and two were retired restaurant owners or managers.
Over all, I guess the main test was comparing the Carolina Reaper powder to the 7 pod Primo powder that I had just finished that morning. These two fresh peppers had the same kind of burn to them but had different qualities of taste, heat levels, and length of heat. We were wondering how that would work when made into powders.
Last year when we compared the Butch T pods to the Moruga pods, we found that the Butch T pods were hot, but dropped off faster than the Moruga pods. The Morugas also had a bit of a stronger good taste, where the Ts were just a bit watered down compared to the Morugas. I guess I should note on this, that I have never received material from Butch himself, which I hear his pods are better than the ones I got a hold of. Mine come from plants purchased from Refining Chilis. Anyway, when we compared the powders of these two scorpions, there was no real discernable difference between the two. That is why I sell "Scorpion Mix" powder instead of these two separately.
We were thinking it might be the same with these two new peppers, but you never know and that is why you do the tests, right? Everyone tried the Reaper Dust first. We gave everyone about 5 minutes and then everyone tried the primo powder. I made little piles on a plate that were as equal as I could do by eye. The result was almost unanimous. One person thought the Reaper was hotter and he liked the taste better. But, 9 out of 10 people said the same thing. From my own opinion, The Reaper had a pretty decent taste to it, but it is somewhat flat tasting. It is there, but it doesn't jump right out at you. The Primo powder has a taste that seems about 50% richer, or stronger. It is also a really good taste that jumps out at you. The reaper had heat that hit you at once and stayed at that same level for a while, where the Primo, even in powder form, took about 30 seconds to reach a peak. People would try it and say wow, thats good, but then you would see it on their face about 30 seconds later. Like holy crap, man thats really hot, and then they would grab their beers and suck some down quickly. It was funny to watch what I already knew was going to come because I always try to test these things first just in case there is anyone who says, hea, I didn't see you try that! The heat on the Primo powder was also hotter. Hard to say how much hotter. It wasn't like twice as hot, maybe something like 30% hotter.
Well, I think the group is, for the most part, in agreement. For both fresh peppers AND with the powders, the Primos beat the Reapers in both quality of taste AND for amount of heat. The Primos, as a pepper, seem to be way more stable in pod form and consistantcy of heat and taste. If I had to vote, Primos win hands down. Both came from the original sources, so that is not an issue. I thought the Brain Strain was my favorite hot pepper, but I am really liking these Primos. I usually use Bhut Jolokia powder as my little carry around powder container that I bring in to Mexican restaurants and that kind of thing. I'm going to carry Primo powder for now on. Just for kicks, I layed out some of my Bhut powder along side of the Primo powder to compare and my Bhut powder just tastes flat and weak compared to the Primos It was like 1/3 the heat and strength of taste.
I hope Primo gets all the recognition he can get on his pepper. From what I got out of my 55 Reaper seeds, I got about 18 plants that almost all have different looking pods ranging from what they are supposed to look like down to small, long, very smooth pods that look like half length, smooth, Bhut pods. The heat ranges like the pods and the taste just doesn't measure up. Sure, they are hotter than Bhuts, but for all the hype we were hit with, along with the pricing we had to pay, they were not worth all that. The majority of the Primo pods look about what you would expect to see. They have a thinner wall to them cpmared to many of the peppers I'm growing, which will make them even better than most for making powder out of them. They can really tear you up fresh if you eat too much of it, so the powder is a much safer way to go. Tom