Capacity planning is the key differential between everyone's needs ...
Family size, or usual number of mouths otherwise, is the key ...
It's just Danielle and I, and she doesn't even really eat all that much meat, but I like to have meat, and also freeze meat, for easy leftovers that are awesome enough to keep me out of trouble (going out, taking out) ...
I bought the Akorn because the fuel cost of doing a brisket at true low and slow temperatures added too much cost to the cook beyond the already jacked up cost of brisket these days ...
Pork is a much better deal, dollar for dollar, all day, everywhere ...
Today's brisket cook will cost like a mere couple of dollars ($3-5), whereas the same size brisket easily consumed $20 in briquets in the Weber, which just isn't as well insulated or sealed ...
I think folks are cooking 6x racks in the PBC, which would always be more than enough for me and mine, but wasn't enough for Booma recently, I think he did 10x and also cooked a bunch of other stuff (I can't recall if the whole hog was part of that cook, or a separate one) ...
I could envision doing 2 racks on the main grate of the Akorn, and a nice pork butt up top ... eating the racks hot, and pulling the butt for future grubbage ... on like $2 fuel ... now we're talking ...
So yeah, it just depends ...
If you've got 4-6 mouths, or want to vac pack a bunch, you probably want an efficient fire and a big capacity - like an offset, or a big UDS or two ...
I would just be wasting a shit ton of fuel to keep a chamber of that size hot, and there's no point eating leftovers instead of fresh, either, since I work from home ...
The real beauty of the Akorn is that you can just leave the lump in the bottom and top it off for each cook, always just adding more, and dumping the reportedly small amount of ash from the pan (which is easy) ...
I've seen people using little stainless 1/4 sheet pans and foil to great effect, making the clean-up a breeze ...
I don't know, we'll see how things look after the cook, but this thing could be my new best friend ... just lit it w/ the Iwatani torch, let it run opened up for 4-5 mins to get going well-enough, and then shut her down and let it stabilize while I got the food ...
For $300, this thing will save it's cost beyond the Weber in fuel savings in the first 6 months of moderately heavy use, and within a year certainly ...
I'm glad I put it into service, finally. It's running nice for me so far ...