Hey everyone, this thread has actually brought up some interesting points and good discussion - even if a bit heated/dramatized. Unfortunately, it is very tangentially related to the REVIEW of Pex's product, so I'm staying out of it.
If somebody wants to open a thread about the pro's and con's of state and federal watchdogs in the hot foods industry, I may even join in the discussion. I think the proper forum would be the "Food Business" forum or maybe "Hot Talk" or "Food and Beverage".
Surely you're not so naive as to believe that product reviews and product business are unrelated?
Reviews drive sales. Sales by a business. In this case, an illegal business.
Reviews are a form of marketing & promotion. If you want to give Pex feedback on his sauces in a PM, no one would take issue with it.
But here your review topic on a hot pepper oriented website can potentially drive sales to his site - where he is illegally selling sauce & reportedly charging sales tax inapropriately. In that regard you are doing everyone a disservice - and it's perfectly appropriate for people to point out the questionable legality of that product. Because you're promoting it on a public forum.
If Pex sold firecrackers on his site would you think it ok? Would you question those who would challenge it?
So thanks, but I find your referral to another board to discuss legality disingenuous - you're promoting something that's not legal to sell and then acting like people calling it out are the ones with the problem. That's simply not logical.
I agree the tone of this discussion could at times have been more civil (and said as much) but it's an absolutely appropriate discussion to have right here because this is the illegal product specifically in question. This isn't a general esotericic or philosophical question here - its a here and now question of letigitamacy.
Again - I'm all for Pex trying to start up a gig. There's no malice whatsoever on my part. He's got a cool logo & I'm sure a tasty sauce. But he's about 500 steps away from having a legitimate food business and taking those shortcuts isn't some constitutionalist stand, or rebellion against the man, or any of the other wildly out there ways this has been painted. And those pointing it out aren't pro- big gob'ment or anti-little guy or any of that crap either.
Some pretty outrageous claims have been bandied about in attempt to counter the simple fact that this is a promotional topic for a product not legal to sell. That's the long & the short of it.