Being a long time fan and a fan of " The Great Bird of the Galaxy" Gene Rodenberry and the fact they blew Vulcan away and rewrote Federation history I give it a D.And Pike did not get hurt on the Enterprise( see The Cage )or a Romulan ship. I will say the best on the show was the fellow who played Bones. Even sounded a little like DeForest Kelly. If this was a whole new show with no history I may have thought differently. I also directed similar comments toward the new BSG and its doom and gloom outlook.
Kevin
Kevin