MrArboc said:Imagine the exact same situation, but the police officer is an american/european soldier and the bike rider is an iraqi man.
Would those of you who want to lynch the police officer still feel the same way? Why/why not? Be honest!
nubster said:Since you were there and saw the whole thing go down....please tell us your perspective.
Armadillo said:When I first read this thread I tended to putting that cop in jail forever. But reading it completely I recognized that I have to compare the situation with physician's malpractice cases. A police officer and a doctor frequently have to make decisions in fractions of a second. And the lawyers and judges and jury members and experts and the puplic and the media have weeks, months or even years to discuss the situation from every possible point of view. It's just not fair.
TOLEDO, OH (WTVG) -- After several hours of deliberating, the jury has found Officer White guilty of felonious assault with a gun specification. He could face up to 11 years.
At around 8 pm on Friday, 13abc learned White was found guilty. That morning, the prosecutor and defense attorney gave closing arguments. Prosecutors say Officer Thomas White failed to protect and serve when he shot Michael McCloskey Junior in the back and paralyzed him. The jury had to decide if Officer White was justified in the shooting.
The defense argued Officer White believed McCloskey had a gun and feared for his life. Prosecutor Jeff Lingo says, "Officer White rushed to judgment, shot, critically injured, permanently disabled McCloskey for traffic violations."
White's attorney Jerome Phillips says, "You don't get a time out and go and tap the individual on the shoulder and say before we enter the next phase, the dangerous phase, where I'm going to have my gun out, and let's talk about this and see what's going on."
LGHT said:Although I can see how the cop would see the guy as a possible threat and that he did reach toward his waist and because it was dark could have had a gun, but what I don't understand is even if he did there is NO way you can turn your right hand backward and actually shoot the gun. I mean think about it turn your back toward someone while sitting in a chair and see if you can pull out a pen from your pocket and point it at the person behind you. Even IF he could have shot the gun all cop cars have bullet proof glass and I'm not sure, but I believe the doors also have bullet proof protection. I mean seriously if you thought you life was in danger why not just get in the car and run the guy over? Why not just sit until the guy gets on the ground when you feel your safe. Why not do anything except pull the trigger?? The problem here is the cop had a LOT of other possible options, but for whatever reason he thought it was best to jump out and shoot. I would chalk it up to piss poor training and bad decision making on the cops part because the incident clearly could have been avoided and handled a LOT better.
MrArboc said:Imagine the exact same situation, but the police officer is an american/european soldier and the bike rider is an iraqi man.
Would those of you who want to lynch the police officer still feel the same way? Why/why not? Be honest!