My first reaction was to respond with ".... now" ... but then I realized that I'm not getting surprised by the outcome from the beers for the most part, so I'm going w/ your statement and taking it at face value.
So, I'll ask a better - albeit related - question ...
TL;DR - Do you think beers are improved by iterations, or better to take a second unrelated crack at it from a new approach if it didn't turn out? ...
I think this goes back to what you are saying ... that you know how it's going to come out before you brew it ...
The reality of my barleywine was such that I brewed it on a whim, just because I was faced with a choice of going to go stand in line to grab some bottles of JDubs barleywine release, or brew beer that Saturday ...
I didn't do a lot of work on the recipe, research the style, or otherwise ... and it wasn't very good tasting ... and ultimately got drain-poured ...
After that brew is when I started to manage pH, and it was between that beer and the next where I started to use the refractometer to track my pre-boil gravity ...
I'm planning to re-brew the Darkness Everybody stout, and I'm planning to re-brew JayWow's beer as well ...
I'm trying to decide whether to seek a BORIS The Crusher Imperial Oatmeal clone recipe and use the bhut syrup in it, or tame down that crazy recipe I used the first time ...
To make it more reasonable I would nix all the Cara's and the maltodextrin and lactose, and do one w/ a reasonable recipe using a more std fare stout base beer w/ oats and rye for body, and step mash starting at like 125F for the BG's, and spent 20 mins for each 7.5F step up to 152.5F over the course of 80-100 mins including transitional time ...
Or, I can find a clone recipe for BORIS, and just work in the bhut syrup into it, as that is the beer I had in my mind when I was making that recipe ...
Since I don't have a strong feeling either way, I'll go w/ your advice in this regard, I think, and either try hard to make a more fermentable stout recipe than the one I brewed, or try hard to vet and adapt a BORIS clone to my setup etc ...
Anyways, just curious ... been on the fence on this one for a week or more already!
=)