I have similar experiences with seafood. I'm not the biggest fan of "fishy" fish. What it sounds like is that you like a lean white flaky fish, i.e. grouper, flounder, halibut, id say mahi mahi even. snapper is a bit fish, so probably not that, but maybe swordfish? The first time I made ceviche was actually in cleveland, I made it with Turbot, Swordfish and halibut. You might also be very fond of kingfish, wahoo and if you can find it, cobia. Coba is my prize fish I love to eat. But at the same time, if you can find a big trigger fish, I call those the pork chops of the sea. Nice thick filets of white meat. Every time I catch a Mahi, after I filet it, I use my knife along the parts that i missed to make very thin slices, as if I were making carpaccio. I would actually suggest this style of thing slicing over the "chunking" you see in your standard suviche, as the texture could throw you off of the first time. But in all honest, it's a very fresh tasting dish, just have to put fresh ingredients, cilantro garlic citrus juice, diced peppers etc
grantmichaels said:
I grew up not liking fish ...
Eventually, after college, I found fried grouper ...
Then I realized that I loved to catch and eat snook ...
Then I found I liked shellfish (my mom was really allergic, so we didn't have it growing up) ...
Then I found I could make the flounder she massacred growing up, better ...
Then I tried some other fish last year ... liking halibut a bit more than grouper ...
And that's where I'm at ... so far ...
I do have a source for fish I'd trust to try ceviche with, so I mostly just need to try to nail the right recipe for me to start with, so I have a good experience ...
I'm a cautious seafood eater, I guess ...
I find the taste and smell of cooked/cooking salmon entirely offensive ... all that lox and capers my family was eating w/ bagels ruined me early on, I guess ...