Pepper-Guru
eXtreme
Oh, I've seen his flickr and even gave him props for his stuff, but dude, Im not trying to shoot anything down here, go back and take a look at Potawie's plants...sure they seem to be rather large compared to their surroundings in the pics, but take away not only the height of the containers (1-2ft) but also the raised tray structure that all the containers are on and imagaine that those plants' bases were at ground surface level. We are really talking about plants that are mearly 2-3ft in height max. Now go back to look at my garden when I lived in the apartments, those plants are nearly as tall as I am (5'8) AND most of the largest ones were 5-6ft in diameter at their best. NOW imagine that my plants were in large, raised pots and then they would REALLY look like Fatalii trees! Seriously go back and look at the pics and just consider what Im saying, know what I mean?Pepper Ridge Farm said:I have no doubt that you just lost 100 bucks Pepper-Guru. Look at Potawie's photobucket account and look at all his plants. Sorry dude.
Thats what I was talking about above. Air Pruning. Just the difference between a root system with a healthy, fibrous structure and one that has been forced to circle a container wall. Look, dont get me wrong I enjoy container garden just as much as the next guy....LOOKAlabamaJack said:ah, but yes...if the roots of the plant never get bound in a container, the container would win hands down because of the control of the "micro-environment" you have created for the plant....right?
and the watering system
All this is symantics really, and it just boils down to superstitions and traditions that you the grower choose based on past expereiences. Everyone has their things that they do... And in the end its all about growing the way that makes you feel comfortable, if growing in containers makes you feel good then your garden and plants deserve nothing short of the best vibes possible from you. I posted this same message last night but I have no Idea where it went, when I got on this morning it was gone so I had to remember most of what I had typed and reply again...lol. I think all this started with me just hoping that PRF would put at least one of those Fataliis in the ground so it could stand a chance against my trees But its all in fun, really.
p.s. PRF and Potawie, I won't be giving up that 100$ anytime soon, however, if you prove me wrong, Im a man of my word. So its as simple as considering this experiment and going through with it.